Here are the official starting lineups for both Everton F.C. and Manchester City F.C. for their Week 35 Premier League game from the 2025/26 season on 4 May 2026 (Monday night). Everton drew 3:3 against MCFC at the Hill Dickinson Stadium in this game- a draw that could effectively end up costing Man City the title.

Everton F.C. vs Man City F.C. 3:3 Starting Lineups and substitutes 2026 Premier League

Pickford (GK)

O’Brien, Tarkowski, Keane, Mykolenko

Iroegbunam (Armstrong 90+6), Garner

Dewsbury-Hall (Alcaraz 90+2), Rohl (Patterson 90+2), Ndiaye

Beto (Thierno Barry 64)

MCFC playing XI vs Everton FC May 2026

Donnarumma (GK)

Nunes, Khusanov, Guehi, O’Reilly

Nico Gonzalez (Kovacic 75), Bernardo Silva (Marmoush 87)

Semenyo (Foden 74), Cherki, Doku

Haaland

Everton FC vs Manchester City FC 3:3 Match Timeline 25/26 Prem League

0:1 Doku goal 43
1:1 Thierno Barry goal 68
2:1 Jake O’Brien goal 73
3:1 Thierno Barry goal 81
3:2 Haaland goal 83
3:3 Doku goal 90+7

Man City had 75% possession in this 3:3 draw against Everton in May 2026.